Following on from his acclaimed Beethoven symphony cycle, Riccardo
Chailly www.riccardochailly.com and the Gewandhausorchester, Leipzig www.gewandhaus.de have turned their attention to Brahms. Decca www.deccaclassics.com/gb have just released a handsome new set of
the Brahms symphonies together with the Tragic Overture, Haydn Variations and
Academic Festival Overture. Also included are 9 Liebeslieder-Walzer, 3 Hungarian
Dances, two Intermezzo from his Opp.116 and 117, as well as the revised opening
to the fourth symphony and the first performance version of the Andante of the
first symphony making the three well filled discs something of a Brahms feast.
478 5344 - 3CD |
Chailly makes a purposeful start in the opening of the Un poco Sostenuto – Allegro with playing
that is muscular, taut and flexible. He creates so much tension in the music.
There is also great clarity, not only because of the fine recording, but from
the way Chailly and the orchestra reveal the instrumental detail. It is
remarkable the way he pushes the music forward yet allows the orchestration to
be clearly revealed. His flexibility of tempi, moving from muscular playing to tender
moments is superb.
A wonderful Andante
Sostenuto, beautifully judged, allows the music to ebb and flow so
naturally. The Gewandhausorchester are on glorious form producing some lovely
sounds, with little brass details sounding through and some fine woodwind
passages. There is a wonderfully fleet footed Un poco Allegretto e grazioso again with some lovely woodwind
contributions. Brahms’ cross rhythms are so well handled and, at times, in this
movement there is an enveloping mellowness to the Gewandhausorchester’s playing
that is so appealing.
Well contained passion opens the Adagio – Allegro non troppo, ma con brio, with wonderfully taut
playing before the Allegro arrives. There are some lovely, long drawn horn
phrases with Chailly getting it so right as he draws the music along. The more moderately
paced passages aren’t allowed to drag and soon Chailly whips the music up as it
leads to the final climax before a terrific coda.
Of all the symphonies of Brahms, this is the one that
underwent the most revision after that first performance. The major revisions
took place just before publishing in 1877 when the entire second movement was
restructured. Brahms destroyed the score and orchestral parts of the original
version, however, an extra set of string parts held in the Gesellschaft der
Musikfreunde, Vienna www.a-wgm.com has enabled a reconstruction of the original
Andante second movement which is included on Disc 3 of this set. Most listeners
will soon notice the differences in this fascinating supplement to the first
symphony performance.
Disc 1 continues with
Brahms’ Symphony No.3 in F major, Op.90 where Chailly again hits the
perfect tempo for the opening of the Allegro
con brio – Un poco Sostenuto. As the music quietens he extracts such lovely,
detailed playing from the Gewandhausorchester with musical phrases that are so
beautifully turned. There are terrifically powerful string sounds and some great
rubato
The winds of the Gewandhausorchester play superbly in the
opening of the Andante as do the
strings, so sonorous. As the music progresses there is a lovely freedom to
their playing, taut yet free and a lovely glowing coda. In the Poco allegretto the strings of the Gewandhausorchester
again show their terrific sonority with Chailly pointing up the details in the
wind section. The Allegro has a
terrific opening, full of anticipation before the orchestra suddenly erupts, truly
joyful and triumphant. The magical coda is finely done.
The second disc in this set brings Symphony No.2 in D major, Op.73 with rich flowing sounds from the Gewandhausorchester
before the Allegro proper arrives.
There are lovely pointed woodwind passages and more taut playing from this fine
orchestra. The woodwind decoration is beautifully done and there are some
lovely glowing passages. Chailly builds to some fine climaxes. It is wonderful
how he keeps such a momentum whilst not glossing over the detail and poetry of the
music.
What Chailly brings to what must be one of Brahms’ finest
Adagios, is the ability to slowly allow the music to feel its way, creating a
feeling of great anticipation. He can really whip up a storm, as in the central
section, but can quickly move from taut drama to reflection so naturally. There
are some magical moments in this movement and a great climax before the peaceful
coda.
There is a lovely, almost relaxed, Allegretto grazioso (Quasi Andantino) with a rhythmic litheness is
so appealing. Chailly has got Brahms’ precise tempo marking just right. Suddenly
the Presto ma non assai arrives with
superb articulation and precision, given a somewhat Mendelssohnian feel. The
final movement brings a real Allegro con
spirito. Chailly allows the quieter passages just enough room to breathe
without losing momentum - quite wonderful. He also makes the most of Brahms’
string sonorities here, whilst keeping a light touch, as the music surges
forward. And what a glorious coda – triumphant.
The Allegro non troppo of the Symphony No.4 in E minor, Op.98 opens with some lovely flowing
string playing, slowly increasing in intensity with fine shaping of phrases.
The quieter interludes help build the expectation, always purposeful, never flagging.
There are so many little orchestral details that show through.
What a terrific Andante
moderato there is, full of lovely sonorities in the gentle melody and some
great, incisive playing at the central climax after which Chailly paces the
slow down so well with another glowing coda. The Allegro giocoso shows the terrific ensemble from the Gewandhausorchester
in this joyful and ebullient performance, full of energy, finely controlled.
How Chailly handles the tempi changes in the Allegro energico e passionato is remarkable,
his control is wonderful, with the Gewandhausorchester playing with the
flexibility and tautness of a small ensemble. Chailly really lets rip in this
finale with superb playing, full of drama.
After completing the fourth symphony, Brahms added four bars
of music as a prefix to the first movement Allegro, a typically Brahmsian wind
chord that falls away into the opening music that we all know. Chailly and the Gewandhausorchester open this extract by playing the last few bars of the first movement
followed by the alternative opening thus giving us a chance to compare the
cadence that ends the movement that was reflected in the revised opening. Brahms
was obviously not convinced about this new opening as it did not appear in the
published edition.
It would be easy, after such wonderful performances of the
symphonies, to overlook the works contained on the third disc of this set. As
well as the original first performance version of the Andante to the first
symphony there is a fine Tragic Overture,
Op.81, full of drama, taut energy
and fine detail and atmosphere, arguably one of the finest on disc; and a
finely wrought Academic Festival
Overture, Op. 80, to which Chailly brings real verve and some lovely brass
timbres.
Two worthwhile shorter pieces, beautifully played, are
included, the Intermezzo, Op. 116 No.4 (Adagio) with a lovely Brahmsian lilt and a warmly
glowing account of the Intermezzo,
Op.117 No.1 (Andante) both orchestrated by Paul Klengel (1854-1935)
Brahms’ Variations of
a Theme of Joseph Haydn, op.56a (Variations on St. Antoni Chorale) highlight Chailly’s ability to move so naturally
from one tempo to another as he does between the variations of this work. The Gewandhausorchester
follow every nuance and turn with Chailly breathing life into the music.
There is a lovely interlude with eight of the Op.52 and one of the Op.65 Liebeslieder-Walzer in Brahms’
own orchestration, nicely shaped, some full of gentle charm and others, at times,
bringing a darker depth as well as some terrific energy. It is Brahms’ own
orchestration of three of his Hungarian
Dances that conclude this magnificent set, superbly played, taut and full
of panache.
This, in my view, is the finest Brahms symphony cycle to
arrive for many years and must become a top recommendation. This generously
filled set is superbly recorded in the Gewandhaus, Leipzig.
The three discs are contained in a bound CD size book with
excellent booklet notes and illustrations that include photographs of the
autograph full score of the first page of the fourth symphony and the last page
of the first movement of that work, showing the revised opening.